Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Level Designer Contests, discussion about and help with the Level Designer, information about glitches, and levels and level series can be found here.

Moderator: Level Moderator

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby Supershroom » September 23rd, 2014, 4:54 am

Whoa, is it possible that this has been totally misunderstood all the time? This is how it goes:

and for every contestant/duelant, his highest and his lowest rating are excluded for his overall score, while the others still have the same weight each.

which means: for every single contestant, sorry. On Yuri's level the sorted scores are: 16, 16.25, 16.5, 17. So the 16 goes out, as it's his lowest score, and the 17 goes out as it's his highest score. This means in this case, everyone would have two scores being valid, and the table would look like this:

Spoiler: show
1st: Yuri (16.5/16.25/--/--) = 16.375
2nd: MoD, no longer tying (16/--/16/--) = 16
3rd: Amp (16/--/--/15.5) = 15.75
4th: KABOOM (15.25/--/15.75/--) = 15.5
5th: Triple J (15.5/--/14.5/--) = 15
6th, no longer placing: Harmless (15.75/--/13.75/--) = 14.75
7th: Nwolf (13.75/12.75/--/--) = 13.25
8th: 1018peter (15/10.75/--/--) = 12.875
9th: Supershroom (--/--/8.5/13.25) = 10.875
10th: Thefiredragoon (7.75/5.75/--/--) = 6.75

Like I've said several times, these numbers only have few significance as the additional judges are missing. Yeah, you can see that not much is changing, but Triple J and Harmless switching positions happens for a reason. In most cases, all scores are within a short intervall, and in this case there is quite no changing, which is good. But when the intervall is distorted, changes get larger, and it helps to make the table and the scores look more smoothly. I'm tempted to say it this time: A level can't be good and bad at once - if there's a huge gap, it's one or even more judges to have blundered, and either the other judges are right, or the truth lies in between. And there is a kind of approximate truth. Making mistakes at judging is gonna happen to everyone at a time, no one needs to be ashamed of it, and once a judge finds out to have a dubious score, he's probably even assuaged if it doesn't get counted.
Image

Thank you, FF.

Nan's sig! From the previous Secret Santa event!: show
Rating standards: show
1 star: (0 - 5.75 in LDC) These levels need a lot of work. They're totally un-elaborated, and/or inherently flawed due to things like cutoff or enemy spam, or they're untested and there are too many bugs gameplay-wise, in short: Many many things went wrong in such a level.

2 stars: (6 - 9.75) These levels are not terrible, but poor. They're too short, lack scenery or they have errors and/or bugs but it's still barely enjoyable. Again, spend more effort and try to do better. (if it's your first level that I rate two stars, it's not bad. There's a long way you can still go)

3 stars: (10 - 12.75) These levels are about mediocre. They may be still a little bit short, the gameplay is fine but not very original and graphics are also solid, but not breath-taking. Try to keep improving!

4 stars: (13 - 15) These levels are nice, but not the best. Effort has been put into them, there can some professionality be seen in gameplay and graphics, they're a nice experience to play, but there are still things you can do to make it even better. Try to go the extra mile!

5 stars: (15.25 - 20) These are really great levels, those which, as said, I would give more than 15 in an LDC. These suffice many high requirements, and it already goes into subtleties if you want to make them better. These levels are successful all around. Bravo.

These are just general principles I try to follow when rating. Sometimes I don't leave a further comment when rating, most times I do, if you have questions about it, feel free to ask further.
Look at this!: show
My total SM63 level experience: 2803 levels.
Total coins collected in these: 306800

The WITBLO11 Tribute


A showcase of the 25 best levels of 2011, including such fantastic levels as Niveau Victorieux Galaxy, Plastic Beach, Dimension Infinity, Realm of the Heavens/Parallel Spires, and more!

My Level Collection: http://runouw.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=25&t=47186

Other Important Links:
Last Legacy Level Designer tutorial
Eternal SM63 Medal Table
Eternal SM63 Score Table (all LDC scores available)
Top 10 Lists for LDC's (highest averages in a single judging criterion)
Runouw Votes Eternal Table
User avatar
Supershroom
Our local SM63 Spielberg

 
Posts: 1802
Joined: June 21st, 2014, 5:22 am
Location: Filmstudio for SM63. Sometimes also LL.

Runouw Votes Winner
New Years 2016: Best Level Winner (Ride Through The Mines)

Thumbs Up given: 244 times
Thumbs Up received: 126 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby ~Yuri » September 23rd, 2014, 5:08 am

Supershroom wrote: A level can't be good and bad at once - if there's a huge gap, it's one or even more judges to have blundered, and either the other judges are right, or the truth lies in between. And there is a kind of approximate truth.


While I agree with you there, it's all about opinions. While you may like a level, others may find it horrible. There's not really a true statement here, one judge could have seen flaws the other haven't. That's why there's the score system, because it will find the middle point between contrasting judgings.
Image
credits to Nan for this amazing gif ^-^
other sigs: show
Image
Awesome sig made by MessengerOfDreams, way back in 2013. She's awesome <3
Image
Amazing sigbar made by FrozenFire!
Image
Image

Great sig made by Raiyuuni!

Image

Made by Konradix! ^-^ (clickable!)
User avatar
~Yuri
Boo

 
Posts: 677
Joined: December 5th, 2012, 3:09 pm
Location: lost, can you please give me some directions?

Cookie
NanTheDark: "Congrats on winning our duel. May the trees watch over you."

Thumbs Up given: 46 times
Thumbs Up received: 85 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby *Emelia K. Fletcher » September 23rd, 2014, 5:23 am

Supershroom wrote:everyone would have two scores being valid

Sure, let's average just two ratings!


');
');





');





User avatar
*Emelia K. Fletcher
Who's this douchebag?

Error contacting Twitter
Error contacting last.fm
 
Posts: 2926
Joined: July 24th, 2010, 3:40 am
Location: A\//\\/A

Cookie
Venexis: "He had everything out seven hours after I had sent the results, give or take. And most of those hours were in the dead of night, lawl. 11/10 would hire as host of a game show."

Thumbs Up given: 42 times
Thumbs Up received: 211 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby Nwolf » September 23rd, 2014, 5:24 am

Supershroom wrote:Nan, I wasn't complaining about not getting bonus points for the reference, but I was surprised of comments like these:
Nwolf wrote:then there was that freefall part of which I couldn't figure out the purpose.

If a reference fits well into the level, it should be rewarded with bonus points. If it doesn't and it damages the level, it should get a minus. Same with alternate music.


oh that's cool so

it hurt the level in my eyes!

congratulations you prooved my point


Now can we close this topic it doesn't seem to go anywhere anymore except that people hate themselves even more than before
Image

(c) MoD
User avatar
Nwolf
Beware, fluffy

 
Posts: 1072
Joined: May 27th, 2011, 10:27 am
Location: Hunting you

My Precious Memory

Thumbs Up given: 48 times
Thumbs Up received: 87 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby ~MP3 Amplifier~ » September 23rd, 2014, 5:36 am

My last note on-topic (I frickin' hope) is it's not a matter of references should be rewarded, it's more than references could be rewarded. People like me for example don't have much experience with other games, making a reference (unless it's really really a notable reference) would have no effect on me whatsoever, I probably wouldn't even realise there's a reference there unless you told me.

On a...slightly lighter more off-topic note...

I have GOT to change my name to ~MIDI Minimizer~, I ♥♥♥♥ love it. <3
"I treat everyone equally, depending on how much I like them." ~Me
The below image is a montage of my individual highest placing LDC creations, as a reminder to myself that level designing is a part of my life that I can't just leave behind

Image
I made this sig so credits to mee :amp smile:
User avatar
~MP3 Amplifier~
THE DARK LAMP

Error contacting Twitter
 
Posts: 4383
Joined: May 6th, 2011, 12:35 pm
Location: Maaars d(^_^)b

SM63 Level Designer Contest Winner
LDC #30: Finale/The Ultimate Battle

Thumbs Up given: 226 times
Thumbs Up received: 611 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby NanTheDark » September 23rd, 2014, 6:24 am

~MP3 Amplifier~ wrote:I have GOT to change my name to ~MIDI Minimizer~, I ♥♥♥♥ love it. <3


Wear that name on Halloween. :3
Some day I'll fix my sig.

Old Sig Stuff: show
Image

Universal Dueling ArenaInto The ShadowsMy SM63 Levels

Image
Made by FrozenFire/lemontea/whatever. Thanks, FF!

ImageImageImageImageImage
????
Image
User avatar
NanTheDark
As it breaks, it becomes stronger

 
Posts: 2018
Joined: December 23rd, 2010, 6:04 pm
Location: Your screen

Runouw Votes Winner
For winning Best Normal Member in the RV Summer 2017

Thumbs Up given: 191 times
Thumbs Up received: 217 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby MessengerOfDreams » September 23rd, 2014, 7:08 am

You've accused people of bias for daring to give your flawed levels a low score. You've accused us of lying about how we feel. You act like we're persecuting you for not wanting this. You're not only telling us how we must judge but what we must be force to give YOU points for. You don't even listen to other peoples opinions, you just try and silence them. And yet we're all misunderstanding and denigrating you?

Please put this topic to rest and stop shoving your rules down to our throat.
Image
Image

My Most Recent Works: show
I switch my signature a lot. If you wanna see some of my past ones, here you go.
Silent Conversations and a Crow's Final Song!
My latest story, and one of my personal favorites. A girl bound in silence finds the words to say to her prospective girlfriend as they visit her religious father in a dusty town on the edge of Kansas, where the crows' migration south brings forth anchored memories, the path to resolution, and a new start.

Form (25quared)
This might be like nothing you've seen before.
Updated Works! Some of my past best and current stuff: show
Writing Works!
Fanfic: Shut Up and Dance
why do I write so much about dancing you don't dance you've never danced in your entire life
lying little ♥♥♥♥ with your ♥♥♥♥ story ♥♥♥♥ you
also Diddy/Lucina <3

Fanfic: Worth a Thousand Words
Because the world needed a Samus/Dedede story
Fanfic: Ecstatic Silence
Just wanted to write and ♥♥♥♥ like this happens, you'd think I'd know better.
Fanfic: Far From the Edge
It's a dance that's been a long time coming for a brand new man and an unchanging woman, but once one takes the plunge there's no falling back up.
Original: Jealous Ghosts of the Mississippi
The story of Rachel meeting Amber after a lifetime of silence and being shunned
Original: Your Hand in Mine
One of my most personal stories about a dangerous romance. Now to be published in a college lit journal!
-------------------------
Recent LDC Work:
Level Series: Leaves From The Vine (ft Star King)
For the 29th LDC, a theme of grassland taken through the growth of our designing society. Won the 29th LDC!
--
Levels at Large:
Level Topic: Collection of MoD's Levels!
If you've ever wanted to see any level I made worth a damn, go here! From the quiet 14th LDC entrant Finis to the megasmash level series Dark, you can find links here!
"You were always a revolutionary, now there's just less of a chance of you crying in the corner." ~Ridder
User avatar
MessengerOfDreams
Moderator

Error contacting Twitter
 
Posts: 6615
Joined: August 16th, 2009, 11:31 am
Location: When I figure it out, I'll let you know.

Winter
2016 Story Contest

Thumbs Up given: 519 times
Thumbs Up received: 707 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby -BY » September 23rd, 2014, 7:24 am

Nou amp. How should I recognize you properly then? D :
As for the topic I'm done and ask for not getting mentioned in any further examples or statements. Like seriously. I'm not feeling like getting too involved.
Image

Big thank you to FrozenFire who created this masterpiece. : )
User avatar
-BY
Honorary Member

 
Posts: 900
Joined: May 23rd, 2012, 11:43 pm
Location: 298

Razzian Fighter

Thumbs Up given: 72 times
Thumbs Up received: 100 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby ~MP3 Amplifier~ » September 23rd, 2014, 7:39 am

I'll just do it for halloween then. ;)

While it's been heated in this topic (so much that I've had to remove my metaphorical jacket), it's still up to Shroom whether or not we should just close the case as he made the topic and if he wants me to, I can lock it. If it's aggravating everyone though I may decide to lock it anyway. Maybe it would be a good idea to draw some final conclusions about the idea anyway so we can just let this topic die peacefully.
"I treat everyone equally, depending on how much I like them." ~Me
The below image is a montage of my individual highest placing LDC creations, as a reminder to myself that level designing is a part of my life that I can't just leave behind

Image
I made this sig so credits to mee :amp smile:
User avatar
~MP3 Amplifier~
THE DARK LAMP

Error contacting Twitter
 
Posts: 4383
Joined: May 6th, 2011, 12:35 pm
Location: Maaars d(^_^)b

SM63 Level Designer Contest Winner
LDC #30: Finale/The Ultimate Battle

Thumbs Up given: 226 times
Thumbs Up received: 611 times

Re: Discussion about a reform on LDCs

Postby Doram » September 23rd, 2014, 9:15 am

A) I'm not sure everyone in the last two pages read my rebuttal.

B)
Supershroom wrote:Like I've said several times, these numbers only have few significance as the additional judges are missing. Yeah, you can see that not much is changing, but Triple J and Harmless switching positions happens for a reason. In most cases, all scores are within a short intervall, and in this case there is quite no changing, which is good. But when the intervall is distorted, changes get larger, and it helps to make the table and the scores look more smoothly. I'm tempted to say it this time: A level can't be good and bad at once - if there's a huge gap, it's one or even more judges to have blundered, and either the other judges are right, or the truth lies in between. And there is a kind of approximate truth.


Right there, you say there is not a lot of change, you agree that this fact is good, and this leads me to believe YOU are missing OUR point that this means our system is not broken at all. Also, you admit to an approximate kind of truth which is exactly what the averaging is supposed to show. Yes, clearly some numbers will change. Change ANY part of ANY equation, and the numbers will change. But the fact that the only changes were neighbors switching proves that our system is still getting reasonably close to showing what is going on, and the only difference is if we start adding or subtracting numbers to the equation to fiddle with it. This is NOT an exact science, nor will it ever be, and the best we will ever achieve is an approximation of universal truth, and I see no evidence that your equation is any closer to that than ours.

Yes. We can experiment with other systems, as some of us already are, and we can try to see if there is anything left to refine, but if the ultimate goal - the ultimate truth - is something as nebulous as "Is this level good, or better than other levels?", then there is a limit - a limit I believe that we have already hit - to how accurate, fair, or otherwise close to the "truth" ANY process can be.

Furthermore, as I have said before, making the process more complicated makes it take longer and provide more chances for people to make mistakes. KISS
Martin Luther King Jr. wrote:Man must evolve, for all human conflict, a method which rejects revenge, aggression, and retaliation.
The foundation of such a method is love.
More words from a wise man on activism, terrorism, violence, and peace
User avatar
Doram
Global Moderator

 
Posts: 1524
Joined: February 22nd, 2010, 7:37 pm
Location: Wherever I'm needed.

Cookie
l.m: "For fixing the stuff I break, and for being the best Forum Dad. XOXO <3"

Thumbs Up given: 153 times
Thumbs Up received: 471 times

PreviousNext

Return to Super Mario 63 Level Designer