runouw.com

XD We could replace DY's judging with a big, giant thumbs up.

Good job, Doram!

I MADE FOURTH! \ /

I'm just happy the judges all had something positive to say about my comic. :3

Nice job everyone!

The second I saw Doram's comic. I was like. THAT ONE! THAT ONE NEEDS TO WIN!


Anyway, What do you mean by replacing my reviews with a thumbs up Moy?









Be that way! You guys didn't like my comic. I DON'T LIKE YOUR COMICS! No, just kidding. Even though that's lower than I thought I'd get. I definitely got higher than I thought I'd get from Ridder!



Thanks for letting me judge! I'll have to join more contests here. And thanks for at least rating my comics more than 2!

Dark Yoshi wrote:The second I saw Doram's comic. I was like. THAT ONE! THAT ONE NEEDS TO WIN!
Anyway, What do you mean by replacing my reviews with a thumbs up Moy?

See, the thing is, when you judged, you gave nearly everyone a perfect 20/20. Art contests need judges who can judge thoughtfully and provide some sort of constructive criticism if the art is not perfect. You gave nearly every comic a perfect score without much reason. In other words, you're reviews were heavily unreliable, which is why Suyo didn't count your reviews.

Just browsing for two minutes since I have free Internet in this hotel.

---

F*CK YEA

Third place WOOHOO

Congrats to Doram and Suyo for the first and second places!

And thanks DY for the perfect 20 even if it doesn't really deserve it

I hope other Comic Contest will occur, it's really cool!

I actually had reason for perfect scores, guess I didn't give enough though. Or you didn't read it...



But what else do I expect from Ridder than bashing out anything I do? Nah, just kidding...

Look at your reviews, now back to ours, None of the judges other than you rated higher than 16, you know, because these comics aren't perfect.
We saw flaws in the comics, plenty, actually, and pointed a lot of them out, but provided thoughts and constructive criticism.

When you rate everything a "perfect" (i.e. 10/10) or "absolute ♥♥♥♥", (1/10.), Then you have to provide well thought-out reasons.


If you want to really find out why your scores were not counted, triplecheck our reviews and compare them to yours.

...

When I looked at Usu's comic, I didn't go WTF, I thought 'Is that a PC-98 Touhou or Seihou'?

But, anyway, congrats, guys! I hope there WILL be another Art Contest, so I can fail at it.