Page 1 of 2
Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier List?
Posted:
August 28th, 2013, 11:09 amby CedarBranch
I'm not capable of working on one myself, but I'm curious if anybody else would be willing to, or if there're already plans.
A Tier List for LL might give the LL Level Portal more activity, but it may also be extremely helpful when comparing the level designing skills users have between SM63 and LL. It could tell more about somebody's actual level designing experience - is the user truly good at LDing in general? Or just SM63 [because they're used to it]?
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 28th, 2013, 11:49 amby Megar
If there are more people who play LL, perhaps. I'd only do a Top 10 thing, though.
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 28th, 2013, 11:58 amby Nwolf
JRFD
First half of the rest
2nd half of the rest
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 28th, 2013, 12:03 pmby Raz
Once more people start LDing. And once SM63 stops hogging all the LDC space
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 28th, 2013, 6:11 pmby JSlayerXero
the problem I forsee with this is that there aren't really 10 people to even make that. I would back this if there were more people though.
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 29th, 2013, 1:25 amby Buff_
I don't like the tier list. It's exclusively run by one person, and it's all subjective. You then get one person's opinion treated as a fact even if your own list is entirely different.
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 29th, 2013, 7:46 amby Nwolf
What if a team of people, maybe 6, run the LL (and maybe also the SM63) tier list so it's not only one person's opinion
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 30th, 2013, 11:18 amby *Emelia K. Fletcher
Then it's not one person's opinion, it's six people's opinions. It's always going to be opinionated, and having more people with a say will either cause chaos or some lopsided compromise.
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 30th, 2013, 11:48 amby Raz
If that's the case, then I don't think we should have a tier list at all.
I agree with buff, I've never thought of the tier list that way.
Re: Do U Think the LL Designing Scene Should Have a Tier Lis
Posted:
August 30th, 2013, 12:15 pmby CedarBranch
So there is no such thing as a fact? Just opinions? So, is the Earth really flat? World Records are only opinions? Volkove isn't the best designer on the site? Runouw didn't make this site? So, we are all dependent on opinions to get things settled? That is what the conclusion seems like to me.