Who should be in SSB4?

[Muffin]

I think smithy and all other super mario RPG characters should be included. Smithy could turn into his final boss form as a transformation and have a big pillar insta-kill everyone for a final smash. Geno could use Geno Flash as a final smash. it,s just crap that Square Enix owns all the characters.

[nin10mode]

NO INSTAKILLS. It should at least have some sort of way to dodge or avoid it before being instakilled. Anyway, one character per thirdparty character. I can't stress it enough. Smash Bros. is a NINTENDO trademark, and should stay that way. Otherwise, it wouldn't be Smash Bros. So pick one out of those two, please.

[tnt175]

First of all, DY, your first post is way too full, and if nintendo would follow it, the All-Star mode would be f***ing too long.

Also keep in mind that the most of the characters in Brawl might come back

There a LIMIT of characters they can put on a game.

Third-party characters can cost alot to nintendo for putting them in the game. (You know about the copyrights?)

The characters need also a good move palette and balanced stats.

[nin10mode]

*directs tnt to my list at the end of the last page*

You likey?

[tnt175]

Not bad...

But the next SSB might have more characters than SSBB. But not too much. *looks at DY rooster*

[destroyer1]

Not bad...

But the next SSB might have more characters than SSBB. But not too much. *looks at DY rooster*

True! Heck, you want long, you should see the roster for Smash.


Runouw, i got a question, if your making a fan game, is it true that you don't need permission from Sega/nintendo... etc...

[TheMMMification]

Runouw, i got a question, if your making a fan game, is it true that you don't need permission from Sega/nintendo... etc...

That's true, you just have to give credit to them, but this is off-topic.

Ontopic: Yeah, DY's list is long and impossible. It just looked like he took all of the characters he thought would be in brawl, and put them together.

[daniellikesmario63]

Here, my own list.

Mario
Luigi
Bowser
Peach
Link
Zelda/Sheik
Ganondorf
Pit (Kid Icarus UPRISING-based moveset)
Samus/Zero Suit
Ice Climbers
Kirby
Meta Knight
Fox
Falco
Krystal
Captain Falcon (Duh)
Pikachu
Jigglypuff
ZOROARK
Mr. Game&Watch
Marth
Roy
Ike
Ness
Sonic
Snake
Crash
Megaman.

That's exactly 30 characters, including transformations. One character per third party. Not completely oversized, keeps all the veterans (If anyone hasn't figured it out before, Ness, Captain Falcon, and Luigi have been in all three games so far, so I tried to keep them in the roster), no broken and overpowerful bosses as characters, and keeps a lot of characters from brawl, so experienced smashers can adapt quickly.

WIN, and the one in bold is fixed

[Ridder]

DY's Roster: Uncontrolled, hardly any thought to it, looks like you just thought of characters you liked and threw it all in there.


Destroyer's Roster: Sigh + Facepalm.


Nin10mode's Roster: Controlled, but I'm afraid Wolf can't let you do tat Nin10mode.

[Buff_]

Methinks the Spy from TF2 should be in the roster. Backstabbing instakills and going invisible. Only deadly razorbacks can stop him.