Re: The Secret Meadow
We're handling it, we don't need for-hire detectives. Albeit slowly, but y'know, seeing ratings isn't a thing that's coded in.
entertainment.net wrote:So I’m not sure if this topic is about the level or downvoters, but here’s a review anyways:
(FrozenFire recommended I do this fyi)
First off, I played this level (albeit badly) and shared my first impressions on YouTube, so if you want, you can check out what I have to say there.
Here’s my overall thoughts on the level:
…
It’s interesting. It’s hard, deep story-wise and well crafted graphically all at the same time, which is not easy to pull off, so kudos to you for that. So yes, it’s great level. But…
I found two things while playing:
One, I couldn’t beat it. At least without cheating. However, I am really rusty at SM63, as you can see in the video, so it’s not that major. I enjoyed playing, if not getting a little frustrated in the process.
What really bothered me however, is the story. I do think it’s interesting and complex, but I found the sudden snap back to reality too sudden, and way too much of a tone shift. To be honest, there wasn’t much story before it, throughout the meadow section. If you were planning to make it about her parents dying, I would have like to see something in said meadow section that indicated it was going to happen, earlier than the bleeding pipe.
All in all though, I like it. If there wasn’t a story and I was rating this based on the great visuals, challenging platforming and just generally the level itself, I’d give you 10/10. However, with my gripes with the story I have to say 9/10.
also i really like the banner for the level