by brandoprojectm » February 26th, 2010, 10:47 am
Hello Mic boy, I finlly got around to reviewing yar second fic. You may realize I don't often review people's fics, but I felt a responsibility to review this one since it's the sequel to a fic I did review.
First, let me start off with some praise. I haven't gotten a chance to get any new cool books from the library, so i decided to print out your little story and read it at home. Let me just tell you that it was just as effective. i usually read books while i eat, but this time my dad even had to take away the printed papers from me. That's how concentrated on them i was. It wasn't Harry Potter, but it did the trick.
Secondly, I've noticed that you did moderately improve your writing. Better word selection, a bit more complex than the one i use in teh kid-friendly Runouw's Forum, but good enough that no one older than 13 gets confused. Your sentence composition and flow have also improved, but it still has some issues that i'll talk about later on.
Finally, the story's plot is kinda wacky at worst, but it still capture my attention very nicely. Your characters are characterized by their words rather than their action like in RF, and you still made it work. You implemented some minor comedy this time around, but there was only one joke that made me lol. i have to personally complement you for your final villian's name: SwineFlu000. Truly a stroke of genius.
Sadly, there exists no decent review without criticisms, so here they are. To start, i want to scold you for your utter lack of investigation and downright lies towards my character in the story. I WOULD NEVER IN MY LIFE WANT TO JOIN THE FORBIDDEN WORDS. MAYBE ONLY IF I WAS POSSESED, OR CRAZY BEYOND HOPW. But still, since this is your story, i guess you can do whatever you want. Still, it doesn't excuse your complete ignorance towards alchemy. Let me teach you something.
YOU HAVE TO ACTUALLY TOUCH THE THING YOU WANT TO TRANSMUTE. AND THE ORIGIN STORY ABOUT THE COLDPLAY CONCERT IS UTTERLY RIDICULOUS. but oh well. Non-FMA fans can't help being uncool.
So yeah, criticims. Remember I told you there were still composition problems? It's true. You've improved, but there are still some sentences I have to read twice to get what's going on. With a bit of practice, you can do a million times better.
There's also the fact that your fight scenes are still....not so good. Add a little detail....surprise...pizzaz! You can make epic battle scenes if you try coming up with original moves and describe exactly what's going on a little better.
Well, that's it! Yes, incredible as it is, there are more compliments than criticims this time around. Your story was really good. Keep up the good work Mic.
PS: Anyone who wants me to review their story, just PM me a printer friendly version. ; )
Just remember this, when you see her on the street.
I'm the cruelest girl you'll ever meet.