We're gonna go 17 on til... how about 11?
#17 BrawlerEX’s You Can’t Escape DeathWritten by: SuperMIC
Ticket to Fame: A surprise 2nd place in the 19th LDC.
Level Type: Platformer
Most Memorable Moment: Navigating the caves then plunging into the river.
This is personally my favourite level from Brawler. His true “je ne sais quoi” style clearly shines in this masterful recreation of Super Paper Mario Wii’s Underwhere, including a completely unique castle stage. Throughout the level, you are faced with great, flowing gameplay and platforming that not only requires you to have precise fingers; however you have to think before you take your next step. This level has not only deserved its 2nd placing in the LDC, it also deserves its high placement in WITBLO12.
#16- Infernal Tower by KABOOMWritten by: MP3 Amplifier
Ticket to Fame: Winning third place in the 22nd LDC, theme being Fire, and getting third in Runouw Votes Winter 2012/13 for the best level of the season
Level Type: Tower, Flames, Platformer
Most Memorable Moment: Entering the tower for the first time and working your way through the variety of obstacles
Until the 22nd LDC, level designer Kaboom kept his talents well hidden. However this simply fun tower platformer is the best example of his recent achievements. Yes, the challenges are repetitive, and yes they are simple, but that's what makes it so fun to play. Unlike many other LDC entrants nowadays, this doesn't aim for the wow moments and the complex innovative gameplay. Instead, it aims for simplicity and it aims for fast yet enjoyable obstacles. This may not be the stand out level & boss of the season, but there is no doubt it provides a wonderfully good fun time.
#15 Big Boo's Rainbow Road by NwolfWritten by: MessengerOfDreams
Ticket to Fame: Fourth place in the 20th LDC (All Things Mario), which has the highest-scoring top 4 of all time. BBRR is the highest placing 4th place level of all time, with its 16.83 score higher than nearly ten LDC winners.
Type: Space, Ghost, Platformer, Replica
Most Memorable Moment: Shooting off to Rainbow Road from the replica of SM64’s Big Boo’s Haunt.
It is incredibly hard to nail a good 2D replica of a 3D level, but Nwolf manages it very well, using tight spaces to recreate the floor plan of Big Boo’s Haunt, complete with a Mad Piano made out of 84 tiny moving blocks. However, this level is only the teaser of what’s to come, as you launch into a replica of classic Mario Kart track Rainbow Road, one of the single most ingenious platforming segments and classic Mario reinterpretations ever seen in SM63. Not only does it look incredible and authentic, it’s great fun to hop along the road, over space rocks and through low gravity segments. This level earns its place as the best 4th placing level of all time, and who better to cement it as such than perpetual fourth placer Nwolf?
#14- Underwhere by blackyoshiTicket to Fame: Winner of the Fire-themed 22nd LDC
Level Type: Hell, Labyrinth
Most Memorable Moment: Rescuing the shade
The win from this contest was the source of a fair amount of controversy, but regardless of whether or not you agree with its placement, the level is a great play regardless, and I can see why it won. The environment is laid out very well, appropriately giving off the vibe of a decrepit, hellish prison that isn't easy to replicate. The platforming is spot on as well, for it is fluid, interesting and enjoyable; it serves as a great challenge without being frustrating, which isn't something that is often achieved. I rarely say this, but I'm a bit disappointed that it isn't longer than it is.
#13 The Blind Experiment by ~MP3 Amplifier~Written by: Yoshi Boo 118
Ticket to Fame: 1st place in the Storytelling part of the 21st LDC.
Type: Story, Platformer
Most Memorable Moment: The discovery of what truly happens within the darkness.
Another level that intertwines story with gameplay so well. Told in a Sherlock story, the mystery and dialogue will keep you intrigued as you explore the vast landscapes. Areas constantly change and transition well in accordance with the story and without one of the elements, this level-story combination simply does not feel complete. The music also works well in setting the mood.
...this next one hurts me for being so low...
#12- MMMMMMM by Yoshi Boo 118Written by: MessengerOfDreams
Ticket to Fame: Fourth place in the intensely heated 18th LDC
Level Type: Puzzle
Most Memorable Moment: Descending down the colorful block chasm and into the most intricate SM63 puzzle on record.
Personally, MMMMMMM was my pick for number 1 in WITBLO12, and I still stand by it. Very few levels are as unique, as intricate, or as masterfully done as MMMMMMM. It’s a level that requires multiple plays to really appreciate the essence of.
MMMMMMM is a tribute to indie game VVVVVVV, but still stands powerfully on its own. With a light yet strong story and some amazing gameplay both in puzzle and platformer, Yoshi Boo draws you into a unique atmosphere that starts out cryptic and mysterious and keeps ramping it up until the heart-pounding final levels. His mix of ingenuity, intricacy, uniqueness, and excellent knowhow of gameplay pays off in this stunning achievement. I stand by it as one of the best LDing achievements, and as time will prove, one of the most underrated.
#11 Temple of Heart by SuperMICWritten by: Yoshi Boo 118
Ticket to Fame: A level that greatly improved itself since its first appearance in the 15th LDC.
Type: Platformer
Most Memorable Moment: Defeating the well-crafted block boss at the end.
This small series is sure to astound, especially since it has been greatly fixed. The platforming doesn’t get stale, and there’s a good variety in its graphics, which are pleasing to the eye. The 3rd part is what really stands out as a boss fight with multiple stages ensues. This truly shows how time and effort can improve a level from its original appearance.
This makes our final 10, in rough chronological order
Omniquet by nin10mode
Dark by MessengerOfDreams
Savage Labyrinth by Volcove
An Act of Antichesm by MP3 Amplifier
Into the Depths by Volcove
Dragon Valley by Star king
Mirror Island by Star king/MP3 Amplifier
Shyguy Island by Buffooner
Timpani and Blumiere- the Untold Story by SuperMIC
Tearing Paper by MP3 Amplifier