Rate the above user's signature

[l.m]

don't rate mine's

though the colors don't for well imo.

fit************************************

remind me to never user phones again

[Raiyuuni]

don't rate mine's

though the colors don't for well imo.

fit************************************

remind me to never user phones again

remind me to never user phones again

[l.m]

suicide is an option

[MessengerOfDreams]

For you, OJ- the sigbar itself is immensely simple, and I especially love the blue/violet tone of the galaxies- it's fitting in helping to recognize that you're a User Rep. I think I took influence from you in keeping this signature because it fit my colors as a mod. So that's very clever. I do think the picture of a galaxy, while nice, doesn't seem overly unique? There's not really artistically a unique touch to this photo, as nice as it looks, and creativity wins in sigbars for me. However, speaking OF your info, it is very nicely distributed. Introduces you well, lets you stash in some cute and funny stuff, and doesn't take its time. Good font choices, too. It's super clean and efficient. Also, your little "working on results" tag is cute-funny. I'll give a 9/10- sigbar could be better artistically but it serves its purpose immaculately.

[nin10mode]

EDIT 1/11/2015: I'm not sorry for killing this thread


So I typed this out to make a point, but I'll review Moy's below all this:

Spoiler: show

Forums Games sure is fun

(Why not move this to General Artwork? We can start a poll, since this honestly isn't even a forum game anymore apparently)

Alright, guess I'll pull out all the stops then.

It took me awhile to get what bothered me about the image itself, but the violet gas cloud on the right distracts from the actual subject of the image, which is your shorthand name/nickname. It's thicker compared to the letters and just larger in general. Without it, the font itself is fine, I guess the filter does its job of contrasting the subject and background, so cool cool.

The meat of your sig is under that spoiler. Format is beautiful, but ways to improve it aesthetically are to make your lack of capitalization consistent (it looks minimalist if it's all lowercase which is fine, but there are things in there that are uppercase which messes it up), give 'hello this is oj' a separate section (because grouping your aka's by themselves makes more sense graphically and the 'hello' can work as a more succinct subtitle for the sigbar which acts as a title) and switch shows and games around to match the other side, and keep messing with that as you update it. If it becomes problematic, think about inverting one in relation to the other or suggesting common text justifications/writing format (I'll make examples below)

inverted:
     sec 1      |     sec 2
       --            -------
     ------            --
       --            -------

indented paragraph
     sec 1      |     sec 2
       --            -------
     ------          -------
     ------          -------

full justified
     sec 1      |     sec 2
     ------          -------
     ------          -------
     ------            ---

flush left
     sec 1      |     sec 2
     ------          -------
     ------             --
     ------           -----

I don't know to what extent you can format these, so maybe you can even justify the columns themselves, but this is all assuming you're stuck with centering.

I don't dig the background color you gave that gif (I can see that it's a transparent background image placed in a formatted box), maybe because it is there all alone with nothing else to counterbalance it on either side. Another thing is that the box doesn't match the horizontal nature of a signature.

At this point, its all my personal taste, but maybe the link can be transferred to the gif and the gif box can be repositioned (and resized using simg if its possible to override the image link) in between the gray columns. You can put a disclaimer directly below that, in the same box, that it isn't your gif or tumblr if it really matters.

9.3/10
Beautiful, minus the gif (box color choice included), could be perfect with fine tuning. Good things get their flaws pointed out hard.

tl;dr eh, we should talk about moving this if we're really gonna take these posts seriously

---

Moy, your sigbar is much simpler to rate because it's just a sigbar, so no wall of text. Still longer though.

I know you love your filters, and at this point, I've just come to accept it (levels with filters over it, I don't know about though, I remember not liking those when that was popular). In this case though, it is indeed aesthetically pleasing because it looks like they support the winter theme, with a hazy, frosted look. In particular, I'm thinking of a flowing water that froze over.

The text is almost fine, and I get that it's spaced evenly from the corner, but I'm thinking keeping it all contained within that ellipse made inside the lightest shade of blue would unify the text more. Shifting it that way would probably fix some inconvenient clashing, too, in particular: the g in single. If not, I think the filters simplify it enough that coloring over a few snowflakes wouldn't be too annoying.

Simple things are cool. Just a minor problem in clashing and a suggestion in visual emphasis. 8.6/10


I guess something interesting that just popped up was that it kinda works with the post itself if its short enough. The post title and rank color are blue, and they flow into your quote which is especially neat, and white text can balance with the bottom of the sig too.

[1018peter]

10/10 - Sleek layouts for a signature. Well organized and gets right to the point without many texts. The pictures on the right are well-placed as well.

[Yoshi Boo 118]

Your sig's pretty neat. I like the variation in color, although I'm not sure why in the green and yellow sections you have varying shades of each on the border, especially since it doesn't look uniform. Also, having your username be semi-bright green along the yellow background makes it kinda hard to read. I like the Porygon and its beam, though. And the inspirational quote adds a nice touch. 8.5/10.

[*Emelia K. Fletcher]

appreciating the display/showcase style you're going for - a slightly (comical?) discordant look and the spoiler is assorted but those are both details i can't pick on that much, it just isn't really too much my preferred style

7.5/10

[gamemaster123]

7.5/10, Design looks a little glitchy, makes it hard to see the name, but I like the color scheme and the C's(?) spread out across. It gives it a nice touch.

[l.m]

I was just going to write a review for MK when you just posted before me. Curse you and your ninja powers.

Anyways, your sig is really uninteresting. There are a lot of broken links, as well as random unfunny quotes - pretty 2009ish. The spoilers don't interest me at all. There's no organization or centering with the links; overall, it's just extremely forgettable. It would be nice if you could at least update the images and fix some of the text. Nothing else to say other than that, really.

3/10